Greenfield Man Scams Locals on Craigslist

Jan. 8, 2014

What started off as a simple transaction turned into a nightmare.

My husband and I are remodeling our kitchen and wanted to upgrade to stainless steel appliances. Since our house is a starter home, some people recommended buying lightly used appliances on craigslist.

After searching through the listings, I saw one that caught my eye. It was a Frigidaire stainless steel convection oven. I personally didn't care if it was a convection oven or not, but I was looking for something newer with five burners, which it had. I called the guy and he said it was two years old and was in very nice condition. At that point, I arranged a time to meet him at his home at 4439 S. 67th St. in Greenfield.

When we arrived, the stove was in the back of a covered pick-up truck and we had to crawl in get a better look. It was hard to see it, but it looked fine. While we were looking, the guy was going on and on about how great it was, how he had paid $1,600 for it. He said the only reason he was selling it was because he wanted to upgrade to an electric stove. When he moved it, I noticed a few pieces of dog food come out from the back. That was a red flag and I should have said no thank you. The man, who claimed his name was John Wills, said "oh, she must have put dog food in the warmer, but that will be easy to clean out." He was very persistent on the price and refused to come down because it was so new and expensive. He then offered to put something in writing guaranteeing me a full refund it I was not happy with the product. I paid $350, loaded it into my vehicle and took it home.

Once home, we started cleaning it and realized that it was from 1995 and had been sitting somewhere for years to the point where it had been infested with rodents. Dog food had fallen behind the warmer and a mouse nest was in the back of it. Mouse droppings were everywhere! (After thoroughly cleaning the back of my car and back porch, where I put the stove, I still have a trail of mouse poop leading from the driveway to my back door!) It was also clear that this stove was different from the photos posted online, but the photos were quickly removed from craigslist.

Completely disgusted, I called John immediately. He didn't answer. My husband and I then loaded it back up in our car, got our 2-year-old son bundled up appropriately for the minus weather conditions and drove back to the man's house. He and a woman were watching the Packer game and refused to answer the door.

I was starting to doubt whether or not the man's name was even John Wills as the mailbox said Jobke and after looking up the property on the city of Greenfield's Web site, I found that the home belonged to Cynthia Jobke.

Not knowing what else to do and desperately wanting this 'rat trap' out of my vehicle, I called the police. They arrived, only to say that a crime had not been committed and my only solution was to file a civil lawsuit. I showed them the paper that he had signed guaranteeing my money back, and they said my only option was to use it against him in court. However, it costs money to take him to civil court.

We went home. Later, I called the man on a different phone, so that he wouldn't recognize the number. He immediately answered. I told him that I didn't want the stove and wanted my money back. He said "do what the cops said and take me to court." He then hung up.

At that point, it was obvious that he had been in this situation before. There was no way he could have heard my conversation with police as they were away from his house and we were talking quietly. This man has done this before, probably many times. He lied about what he was selling and took advantage of me and my husband as a means for him to make money. I am currently out of $350, a substantial loss for a family living paycheck to paycheck.

I know this man, who goes by the name of John Wills, is currently selling a washing machine and stainless steel side by side refrigerator. I wanted to post this to inform others about this man and to avoid someone else from going through the same debacle that I did.

This site uses Facebook comments to make it easier for you to contribute. If you see a comment you would like to flag for spam or abuse, click the "x" in the upper right of it. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use.

Suburban News Roundup

E-mail Newsletter

Your link to the biggest stories in the suburbs delivered Thursday mornings.

Enter your e-mail address above and click "Sign Up Now!" to begin receiving your e-mail newsletter
Get the Newsletter!

Login or Register to manage all your newsletter preferences.

Community Watch

» West Milwaukee school finds a mindful minute goes a long way 11/28

» Mother of 2, day care center director named to Greenfield School Board 11/24

» Greenfield police dispatch two coyotes reported as aggressive 11/24

» Making way for project, Layton Avenue Baptist Church has new location 11/24

» Full advisory committee endorses West Allis high school boundary plan 11/23

» $2 Budget South Cinemas in Greenfield closes as of Monday, Nov. 23 11/23

» Christmas deadline nears for Holiday Helper donations in West Allis 11/23

» Updated state championship game rankings of area prep football teams and players 11/19

» Whitnall participates in global education conference in Washington 11/18

» Plans for National Avenue upgrade in West Allis ready for public input 11/17

» Greenfield residents worried about coyotes get reassurance, advice Updated:  11/17

» Draft ordinance to allow beekeeping in Greenfield clears health board 11/17

» Steering committee recommends West Allis high school boundary plan 11/16

» 169 smoke alarms installed in high-risk West Allis neighborhood 11/16

» Hay wagon collects ton of love for needy West Allis families Saturday 11/16

» Rock band's message to students aimed at kicking pain out of bullying 11/16

» Man cleared in earlier shooting accused of being high before fatal crash 11/12

» After incidents, Greenfield to hold info. meeting on coyote problem 11/10

» No-tax-increase proposed West Allis budget for 2016 going to a vote 11/10

» West Allis neighbors would pay for some traffic slowing measures 11/10

» Greenfield Highlands meets pond-lining deadline, rain needed for test 11/10

» Greenfield photographer's photo winner in bank's 2016 calendar contest 11/9

» Whitnall School District recognized for its efforts to communicate with residents 11/9

» After 2 coyote incidents, Greenfield alderman warns residents to keep pets safe 11/9

» Initial Reaction Podcast: What's the one recent sports question that bugs JP more than anything else? 11/6

View All Posts Got a tip? Welcome rss



Local Business Directory