Greenfield - An 1865 farmhouse might find a new purpose as a 21st-century eatery that at first would house other food-related operations.
Craig Mengeling, of D.C. Capital Investments LLC of New Berlin, and his wife, Debbie, have a long-range vision of creating a 50- to 60-seat garden restaurant, serving Door County fish boil and mesquite chicken deep fry two or three nights a week, at the house.
The property, at 5225 W. Forest Home Ave., is already zoned for commercial use. But the farmhouse, most recently used as an office building, is currently vacant.
Craig Mengeling said the plan is to start small, at first turning part of the house into their business headquarters for their existing concession business and a catering office for clients. The Mengelings would live upstairs.
They also have plans to turn an outbuilding on the property into a small antique and furniture refurbishing center and sales shop.
The couple's concession business includes two uniquely designed trailers, the Hard Wood Café and Wurst Wagon, which sell food on the streets of Milwaukee and other communities at fairs and festivals. The couple wants to park the wagons on the land and assemble already prepared food in the farmhouse to sell in the wagons.
The food wagons also could be opened for business at the site periodically.
Looking further ahead
The couple also envisions a second phase that involves buying the also-vacant 1848 building next door, at 5215 W. Forest Home Ave, where the family would live, allowing them to make full use of the neighboring farmhouse for commercial purposes. That's when the outdoor garden restaurant could come along.
If the city allows the first phase, the second phase might take another year or two, he said.
The rest of the 1865 farmhouse might be converted to a small coffee shop enclosing the outside summer kitchen deck, with the rest of the lower level rooms offering crafts and antiques.
In their application to the city for a special-use permit, business operations would primarily be from May through October, and the couple would try to harmonize the business with the décor and charm of the original farmhouse.
To bring their plans to fruition, Mengeling said the couple would try to satisfy any concerns, including those of neighbors.
"You want them to be happy with whatever you do," he said of neighbors.
A hearing will be held on a permit for first phase sometime in late September or early October.
The Plan Commission last week gave the go-ahead for a public hearing. It also added a requirement that the wagons be screened from view, probably with a wooden fence.
- Jane Ford-Stewart
Your link to the biggest stories in the suburbs delivered Thursday mornings.
Enter your e-mail address above and click "Sign Up Now!" to begin receiving your e-mail newsletter Get the Newsletter!
- Greenfield police report: May 21, 2015 issue
- Veteran's tribute slated for Arlington Park
- Four days of fun, music, food coming to JansenFest in Greenfield
- 30-unit facility for elderly gets nod from Greenfield Plan Commission
- Greenfield to hold public hearing June 16 on proposed Goodwill store
- Greenfield police report: May 14, 2015 issue
- West Allis police report: May 14, 2015 issue
- West Allis veterans groups, city to honor vets with parade, ceremony
- Milwaukee Emergency Center for Animals blood bank filling up in Greenfield
- West Allis Goodwill moves into a larger store